My 3,000 Km Review Of The Motomaster Eliminator X-Trail A/T

Author:

Published:

Updated:

Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

Disclaimer: Canadian Tire gave me these tires for free to test out. This is still a 100% honest review of my experience with them.

I have been preaching for years that the Goodyear Duratrac is the best off-road tire for winter driving. Then, the folks at Canadian Tire told me about the new Motomaster Eliminator X-Trail A/T. They were specifically proud of its winter performance.

In order to compare them during real-world situations, I kept the Duratracs on our 4runner and had these mounted on our 2006 Tacoma. These are very comparable vehicles and they live side by side in our driveway. 

4runner Vs Tacoma

 

It’s worth noting that there are some differences – the size of the Duratracs is 285/70/17 while the Eliminator X-Trails are a narrower 265/75/17. The 4runner is also full-time 4WD and has a torquey-er V8 while the Tacoma has the ability to drive in 2WD with a smaller V6 engine.

 

Motomaster Eliminator X-Trail Overview

The Eliminator X-Trail is the latest off-road tire to come from Canadian Tire’s in-house brand, Motomaster. Its intended use is for daily driven trucks that also hit the dirt from time to time. It’s also a tire that you can leave on year-round – even in the winter.

I’ve read people’s opinions online and it seems like some of them aren’t willing to give these tires a chance because of the Motomaster name. While I don’t see this as a problem myself, I can understand why they might believe that an in-house tire brand might be of lesser quality.

 

Tacoma 265/75/16

 

Who makes the Motomaster Eliminator X-Trail?

Allow me to set your mind at ease here – the Eliminator X-Trail is designed and manufactured by Cooper Tire. Canadian Tire had their hand in some of the aesthetic design, but aside from that, these are essentially made by Cooper.

Many all-terrain tires will boast about their off-road ability but in reality, the tread design is pretty mild. The X-Trail A/T features a fairly aggressive tread pattern, although it’s not as rugged as a mud tire or even an “in-between” tire like the Duratrac

These Motomasters are Severe Snow Service rated with the 3 Peak Mountain Snow symbol displayed proudly on the sidewall. I’m going to assume that a big reason they received that rating is due to the generous amounts of siping on every tread lug.

They’re made with a compound (Adapt Trail Technology) that balances off-road and winter performance with great on-road manners. They also have decent sized side lugs that make them stand out from those less aggressive A/T tires.

So how does the Motomaster Eliminator X-Trail A/T drive?

 

Tacoma 265/75/16

On-road performance

Street driving with the Eliminator X-Trail is one of this tire’s biggest strengths. I know that seems silly since this is meant to be an off-road tire. But when you consider the fact that it’s intended for off-road use, the on-road performance is shockingly good.

I’ve tried street tires that are worse on the street than these off-road tires. That’s seriously impressive. Let’s break down the road manners of the Eliminator X-Trail into a few categories:

 

Noise

This was my biggest surprise, and also my biggest complaint with my aged Goodyear Duratracs. One look at the beefy tread design of these tires and you’ll automatically assume that they’re going to howl on the highway. That couldn’t be more incorrect.

In my experience, the Eliminator X-Trail is quieter on the highway than a dedicated winter tire on a passenger car. Even on a truck like the Tacoma (let’s face it, it doesn’t exactly have the sound deadening, door seals, windows, and audio system that a Platinum Tundra might have) these tires are whisper quiet at highways speeds.

I know I said the same about the Goodyear Duratracs years ago. The truth is, they were pretty quiet back then. Now that they’ve aged (roughly 45,000 km), the sound has certainly changed. I believe the Eliminator X-Trail is quieter with 3,000 km on it than the Duratrac was back then. But time will tell as these tires wear. I’m very interested to see how the noise changes.

 

Tacoma 265/75/16

Vibration

This is another common issue with off-road tires. They can be difficult to balance and often, they’ll vibrate quite a bit at higher speeds. This is not an issue here. While both the Duratrac and Eliminator X-Trail required quite a few weights to balance, neither have a problem with vibrating at speed.

At least, not until over 100 km/h. At that point, you can notice that you have aggressive tires on the 4runner. The Tacoma with the Motomaster tires, however, continues to be smooth at 120, 130, and 140+ km/h. Now, with that said, there’s probably no good reason to be driving that fast in a 4runner or Tacoma.

 

Driving in rain

This is a very popular question when it comes to off-road tires – how bad are they in the rain? You see, over the years, off-road tires have been known to hydroplane in standing water. This was more of an issue with old-style mud tires that didn’t have any siping.

The Eliminator X-Trail has been fantastic in the rain so far. That’s due to the generous amount of siping the tire was given in an effort to boost winter performance. Standing water hasn’t been a problem at all.

 

Tacoma 265/75/16

Off-road performance

I have a confession to make. We haven’t had a chance to do any hardcore off-roading with these tires yet. There are a couple of reasons:

  1. This is my wife’s daily driver and its main purpose is street driving
  2. The 4WD actuator is acting up on the Tacoma and whether it’ll engage or not is unpredictable

So I haven’t done any mudding or rock crawling with these tires yet. Hopefully, I’ll be able to sort out the 4WD actuator and we’ll be able to take it out on an adventure soon.

Hardcore wheeling aside, the Tacoma has seen plenty of rough dirt roads. That’s more than likely the type of driving someone will be doing if they’re looking for a set of tires like these. 

Dirt road performance has been great. The separation of the tread lugs is tight enough that picking up and throwing rocks is not much of an issue. On the other hand, I would assume that these tires might have trouble shedding mud for that same reason. That’s the trade-off, unfortunately. 

The design of these tires is very much that of an all-terrain tire and not an aggressive mud tire. So don’t expect them to be able to go mudding like a Super Swamper or do some really heavy rock crawling. That isn’t the intended purpose of the Eliminator X-Trail. 

This tire is meant to be mounted to a daily driven truck that needs to behave on the street while being able to explore forest service roads and backcountry trails on the weekend.

 

4runner Vs Tacoma

Winter performance

Winter driving was a big focus for Canadian Tire when they came up with the idea for their newest Motomaster truck tire. They understood that performance in snow and ice conditions is typically a downfall of a traditional all-terrain or mud tire.

I think they were pretty smart in making winter driving a priority here. How many 4×4 truck owners do you know that replace their beefy off-road tires with a winter tire? Everyone I know just assumes that off-road tires are meant for adventure regardless of the season or conditions, and leaves them on year-round.

You can absolutely do that with the Eliminator X-trail if you want to. Their healthy amount of siping, rubber compound, and tread design make them great for daily driving in the wintertime.

I had the chance to compare the Duratracs on the 4runner with the Motomasters on the Tacoma back to back in the worst blizzard of the year here in Ontario. You can check that out in the video below:

My findings were pretty interesting. In deep snow, the Motomasters tend to dig through and cause the truck to sink down. They eventually find traction and bite in though. The Duratracs on the other hand, tend to float on top of the snow.

Hardpacked snow and icy conditions were a different story. I can honestly say that the Eliminator X-Trail blew the Duratracs out of the water in this situation. Braking and steering were much better. The truck was more stable when things were slippery. Overall, I had much more confidence when driving the Tacoma in typical winter driving in the city.

The best way to sum up the winter driving performance is that I spent most of the time in 2WD. Arguably, sometimes that was because 4WD refused to engage, but for the most part, I just didn’t feel like I needed 4WD most of the time.

 

Tacoma 265/75/16

Treadwear and longevity

I’ve only logged about 3,000 km on these tires so far so it’s no surprise that they still look like new with very little wear. Canadian Tire claims the lifespan for these is 90,000 km which is seriously impressive for an off-road tire.

I’m not sure if I’ll be able to get there to see if this claim checks out myself, but I will be keeping these tires on for the rest of the time we own this truck. Make sure to follow along on YouTube and Instagram for any updates on how these tires wear.

 

Eliminator X-Trail pricing

This is another big plus for these Motomaster tires. Not only do they list for a considerable amount less than other big-name tires, but they also often go on sale at Canadian Tire. It’s definitely worth paying attention to what sales are on if you’re shopping for a new set of tires. It might make an already inexpensive set of tires turn into a total bargain!

Final Word:

 

The Motomaster Eliminator X-Trail feels a lot like a dedicated winter tire in snowy conditions. It just so happens that you can leave it on year-round, take it on off-road adventures, and cruise home on the highway in silent comfort. In my opinion, Cooper did an excellent job in developing these tires. 

My hope is that people will actually get to experience them and that they won’t become a “best-kept secret” among people that have tried them. I feel like this tire would become hugely popular and give some much more expensive tires a run for their money if they were sold under the Cooper name. 

Will they be able to get enough attention for people to look past the Motomaster brand? I’m not so sure. Hopefully, people will be open-minded enough to read or watch some reviews on these before making their decision because it seems as though everyone that tries them, likes them. 

 

14 responses to “My 3,000 Km Review Of The Motomaster Eliminator X-Trail A/T”

  1. christopher Avatar
    christopher

    just wanted to add that I am a medic in northern BC and all the medic units use Duratrac and in all the years I have never had a problem with them except the Price

  2. christopher Avatar
    christopher

    i just purchased a set after the Hankook’s Dynapac only lasted 49,200KM no heavy loads no excessive speeds no heavy footed driving. so hopefully these Motomaster Extreme will be better on my F150

  3. Ramon Rider Avatar
    Ramon Rider

    Thanks very much for the comprehensive and detailed review.I confirm and agree with your findings in my situation. After switching to studded winter tires for Alberta Winters for over 10 years on my SR5 Foreruner, two years later, still impress with the Motomasters and haven’t looked back. It is also a huge convenience not to have to change the huge tires twice a year ! I still change my wife and daughters tires with the seasons. Lol !

  4. Phil Avatar
    Phil

    Interesting review and comparison to the Duratecs. I am currently running some aged Duratecs – they must have 60K kilometers on them. Tread is down from original 13mm to approx 6mm, grip in snow is still good but summer tarmac driving is getting noisy and I recently had to swap the spare with one of the front tires which had become very lumpy to drive (extremely noisy and lots of vibration, with the wheel off the tire, using a ruler across the tread blocks it was evident that the tread block were not wearing evenly). Now considering The Motormaster Eliminator X-Trail. I need a great winter tire (ice and compacted snow) but I don’t do deep snow very often, but I would prefer something closer to a normal road summer in the summer. So your Motormaster info was interesting – thanks

    1. Tim Rempel Avatar
      Tim Rempel

      Sounds like your experience with the Duratrac is pretty similar to mine. These X-Trails have been awesome on-road!

      -Tim

  5. Ron Avatar
    Ron

    Hi. Owner of a 2019 ram bighorn 2500 6.4 hemi. Owed many rams from 2008 to date, even a Chevy or two. ALL had Duratracs. As a paramedic and alberta Northern county 1st responder, I needed reliability. Well. Today I traded my duratracs with 10k on them for these Motomaster Extreme 20in tires.
    The difference is absolutely unbelievable. Remember I said ALL of my wheels had duratracs.

    I am so impressed with these tires. The road sound is like not there. Plus, My fuel mileage gained. The other thing, the duratracs let me know when I turned with the knobby growl. These new tires are great.
    It’s only mid August. I hate snow but I’m waiting. Eagerly I’ll get back to you

    1. Tim Rempel Avatar
      Tim Rempel

      Glad to hear you feel the same way about them!

      -Tim

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest posts

  • PHOTOS: Toyota’s Winners and Losers at CIAS

    PHOTOS: Toyota’s Winners and Losers at CIAS

    I was able to attend Media Day at the Canadian International Auto Show in Toronto this year and as you’d expect, nearly all the content I captured was from the Toyota booth. Now, please keep in mind that this coverage is coming from the perspective of a Toyota enthusiast, not an automotive journalist (I’m not…

    Read more

  • 9 Ways to Prevent Your Toyota 4Runner From Being Stolen

    9 Ways to Prevent Your Toyota 4Runner From Being Stolen

    If you’re anything like me, you’re constantly thinking of ways to prevent your Toyota 4Runner from being stolen. We worked hard to earn our rigs, and the thought of it disappearing is a hard pill to swallow. No matter where you live, the possibility of auto theft looms, and it pays to be proactive in…

    Read more

  • Tuffy Console Safe Review: Securing My Tacoma!

    Tuffy Console Safe Review: Securing My Tacoma!

    Today, I’m reviewing the Tuffy console safe and rear lockbox for the Toyota Tacoma. We live in a world where simply locking our doors is only enough to keep the honest people honest. Seasoned criminals have no problem breaking a window or finding another way into your vehicle if they want to get in badly…

    Read more