How Much Does Classic Car Insurance Cost And What Are The Benefits?

Author:

Published:

Updated:

Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

In general, classic car insurance costs a lot less than a regular insurance policy. It’s often 50% of the normal cost and sometimes even cheaper than that. The reason is that insurance companies see classic cars as a much lower risk.

What classic car insurance costs: My research

In preparation for writing this article, I contacted a few insurance companies for quotes using my own personal Toyota MR2 as an example. I received ballpark estimates from Haggerty, Rates.ca, Vintage Auto Insurance, and Zehr Insurance Brokers. I’ll also share what I currently pay with Intact Insurance.

A few facts to put these numbers in perspective. I live in Ontario, Canada and have been driving for 21 years with a squeaky clean record. The car is a heavily modified 1991 Toyota MR2 Turbo with an appraised value of $27,685. You can find all the details of that car here: Here are the numbers I was given:

Insurance CompanyPrice Per Month (Quote)
Haggerty$78
Rates.ca
$68
Vintage Auto Insurance
$34
Zehr Auto Insurance
$23
Intact (what I actually pay)
$32

Haggerty pricing

As you can see, Haggerty comes out as the most expensive option, although probably the most popular one. Nearly everyone has heard of Haggerty Insurance thanks to their advertising/sponsorship at the Barret Jackson collector car auctions.

It’s worth noting that insuring your car with Haggerty comes with a few perks. One of the things they’re proud of is their lack of a mileage cap. You can drive your car as much as you want.

Another thing to mention is that Haggerty’s price includes the $55 per year fee for their membership program. This includes things like roadside assistance (with a guaranteed flatbed), members-only events, and a magazine subscription.

If you aren’t interested in these benefits, you might be better off with another company like Intact.

Intact pricing

I pay $32 per month for my MR2 with Intact. This is not a fluke – I’ve been paying this consistently for years with no problems or issues whatsoever.

In comparison, I used to pay more than 4x this amount when my car was insured on a regular policy. At that point, it also had a replacement value of a mere $3,000. That’s a far cry from the appraised value of $27,685 that it’s currently covered for!

Requirements for classic car insurance

Front shot of 2nd gen MR2

The rules and qualifications for insuring your car as a classic will vary based on the company you’re working with and where you live.

Here in Ontario, most companies will consider a vehicle over 15 years old a classic. In other areas, the age limit is higher at 20 or even 25 years old. Sometimes they’ll allow newer vehicles if they can be proven to be special interest or limited production.

There are a few other things that can decide whether your car is eligible for classic insurance:

  • You have a minimum of 10 years driving experience
  • You own another vehicle for daily use
  • You have a relatively clean driving record
  • The car is stored safely indoors
  • The mileage the car is driven every year is limited
  • A vehicle appraisal may be required and may also need to be updated periodically
  • Some modifications may not be allowed (Nitrous, roll cages, etc.)

There could be other requirements that are important to your insurance company so make sure you talk with them about your specific vehicle.

Remember that failure to disclose information can result in your policy being canceled or a claim being denied (that can get really expensive, really quick).

Crimson Red Toyota MR2 Front

Benefits of classic car insurance

Insuring your vehicle as a classic has some great benefits. It’s actually a pretty easy choice, as long as you can meet the eligibility restrictions mentioned above. Here are some pros and cons of classic car insurance:

Pros

  • Guaranteed replacement cost
  • Much cheaper premiums
  • Proper coverage for modified cars
  • Extra perks from companies like Haggerty

Cons

  • 3rd party vehicle appraisal required (additional cost of $180+)
  • Some companies have caps on how many miles you’re allowed to drive per year

Your car is insured properly

Most typical insurance companies won’t understand what your collector car is really worth. They don’t seem to look much further than the model year and manufacturer. This is why they assumed my MR2 was worth $3,000 – just days after I had paid $18,000 for it!

Classic car insurance usually requires a vehicle appraisal. This might seem like a nuisance because you’ll have to track down an appraiser and pay to have it done, but it’s actually a good thing.

The appraiser’s job is to analyze your entire car in terms of condition and modifications, then research the market for cars just like yours to decide what it’s worth. This takes a lot of time and effort – both of which a regular insurance company isn’t willing to do.

Red sw20 mr2 parked near trees

Another reason the appraisal is so helpful is that it documents any modifications done to the car in a way that the insurance company will be content with. They’ll list anything that has been customized and provide photos for the company to see.

Anyone that has owned a modified car knows how picky an insurance company can be about this, especially if they find out the wrong way.

Classic car insurance gives you peace of mind in knowing that the insurance company is aware of every nut and bolt on your car. There doesn’t need to be any secrets and they’ll take a 3rd party’s word on what your car is truly worth. No surprises when it’s time to make a claim.

You’ll pay a lot less

At one point, due to the heavy modifications to my MR2, I was paying around $250 per month for insurance. That was with a crystal clear driving record too. Now, when insured as a classic, I pay a whopping $32 per month. Same car, same driver – nothing else has changed.

Berlina Black Acura NSX

Why is classic car insurance so cheap?

The insurance companies see classic cars as a much lower risk than normal ones. The restrictions that they put in place in terms of storage and limited mileage certainly help.

The fact is, the odds of something bad happening to a collector car are much lower. As gearheads, we’re known for taking exceptional care of our pride and joy. That includes staying up on maintenance, driving them carefully, and sometimes not even letting them out of sight.

We protect these cars because they mean more to us than the average minivan – and luckily, insurance companies recognize this.

When a classic car is used mainly for pleasure, the chances of something bad happening to it drop drastically. For once, we’re being rewarded for being car enthusiasts.

In this case, we aren’t the troublemakers. We’re just the folks that are cruising around late at night with our arm out the window to meet our buddies for coffee. I’m glad that some of these companies understand that.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest posts

  • Readers’ Rides: Ryan’s 2006 4Runner

    Readers’ Rides: Ryan’s 2006 4Runner

    I get a lot of submissions for the #roastmyrunner video series on YouTube and I decided to start posting some of them here in their own feature article. We’re kicking this off with Ryan (aka Dusty4r on Instagram) His 2006 V6 has seen 277,000 miles so far and likely with many more to go. Judging…

    Read more

  • The Story Of How The Toyota Tacoma Got Its Name

    The Story Of How The Toyota Tacoma Got Its Name

    The Toyota Tacoma’s name has a history as intriguing as the pickup itself, tracing back to the Coast Salish people’s original name for Mount Rainier in Washington State. This name celebrates the big, beautiful landform and shows that the truck is strong and dependable. It gives the truck a tough vibe that matches its ability…

    Read more

  • PHOTOS: Toyota’s Winners and Losers at CIAS

    PHOTOS: Toyota’s Winners and Losers at CIAS

    I was able to attend Media Day at the Canadian International Auto Show in Toronto this year and as you’d expect, nearly all the content I captured was from the Toyota booth. Now, please keep in mind that this coverage is coming from the perspective of a Toyota enthusiast, not an automotive journalist (I’m not…

    Read more

Subscribe to Gearhead Grinds

FREE automotive news, car care tips, and exclusive content to be enjoyed with your Sunday morning coffee.

    We won’t send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.